What are we giving thanks for again?

At the midpoint of “Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back,” heroes Han and his friends are on the run from bounty hunters and, desperate for help, seek help from Han’s old friend Lando Calrissian. Lando welcomes them with open arms. He is the perfect example of hospitality. At least, until he turns them over to Darth Vader. To be fair to Lando, he didn’t have the betrayal planned when the group first arrived. Originally, his generosity was pure. Still, it would be odd to make a galaxy-wide holiday celebrating hospitality and sharing based on that first night.

Happy Thanksgiving, Asbury!

Now, I know that “The Empire Strikes Back” is not the first media most of us think of when this time of year comes around. Most of our minds drift to nostalgic programming like “A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving,” football games and the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. I personally can’t think of the holiday without thinking of the picture book my mom used to read to me about the miracle of the first Thanksgiving. But was the first Thanksgiving more like that picture book or the momentary cordiality in “The Empire Strikes Back”? I’ve been wondering. So I started researching.

By the time 90 Wampanoag and 52 English feasted together in 1621, they certainly had helped each other. More specifically, their alliance had led the Wampanoag people (who had already had some contact with English colonists) to help the newcomers with tips about hunting and planting that helped them survive winter. Quite literally, the harvest they were celebrating was the fruit of the Wampanoag’s guidance. So, though the term Thanksgiving was never used, and none of the now ‘traditional’ dishes were present at the feast, the day did mark a grateful moment in the Pilgrims’ history.

That moment, however, didn’t last. In 1675, just 54 years after the first Thanksgiving, King Philip’s War broke out between the English and the Wampanoag. But don’t be tempted to think that those 54 years mean that at least the first generation of English and Wampanoag always got along. In reality, those five decades were filled with cultural turmoil between the Wampanoag and Pilgrims, including the Wampanoag being pushed into smaller portions of land, native farming being destroyed by English cattle and English law being enforced over and above tribal customs. Essentially, these 54 years were a time of English colonists forcing their culture over that of the Wampanoag in their own homeland. When King Philip’s War broke out, it was not a sudden twist of fate. It was the breaking point of a slowly growing conflict.

Not surprisingly, no one at that point considered that first harvest festival a reason for an annual celebration. A nice moment in the colony’s history? Sure. But a short-lived one. And, when considering the whole of American history, far from the normal relationship between colonists and English settlers. 

So when did it start getting celebrated? Following decades of local celebrations of giving thanks around the country, the First Congress in New York City prompted President George Washington to proclaim November 26, 1789, the first national day of prayer and thanksgiving. In the years following, other presidents occasionally proclaimed days of thanksgiving as well, including ones in February and April, though the holiday was neither annual nor tied to a specific historic event. In fact, rather than a politician at all, it was magazine editor Sarah Joseph Hale who deserves the credit for making Thanksgiving an annual holiday thanks to her 36 years of articles and crusading on the holiday’s behalf. Combined with the influence of a book by Alexander Young referring to the Pilgrim feast as “the first Thanksgiving,” her efforts eventually led to Abraham Lincoln finally establishing Thanksgiving as a national, annual holiday during the Civil War.

It’s strange the meaning that we can give to historic events. Originally attached to the holiday to make it more ‘American,’ the Pilgrim story today drives as many people away from the holiday as toward it. In the last week alone, I have had two friends (one of them a history major) admit that they can’t see Thanksgiving the same way after diving into the true story of the Pilgrims, and I get it. We should not celebrate the sanitization of history. But before we dismiss the day entirely, I want to offer an alternate perspective.

The concept of a thanksgiving day was not created out of the Pilgrim story. For local colonial communities, it was a solemn practice of prayer and gratitude. For Washington’s presidency, it was a sign of gratitude for a new nation. For Lincoln’s America, it was a reminder of the importance of unified thankfulness. Instead of spending this Thanksgiving trying to shoehorn our oversized turkeys into a colonial story that is more complicated than we like to admit, I wonder what would happen if we followed the original intent of the holiday. How might our perspectives change if we took November 26 to pray for the state of the world today, and to join with our neighbors in gratitude for the daily blessings we overlook? What if we let the day be solemn? What if we let it be relevant? Not to ignore the difficult past associated with it, but to embrace the original intent that’s been drowned out in controversies and parades.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Take a look at Previous Editions!

Connect with us on Social Media